One afternoon, I was at my apartment, watching football. The doorbell rang, I opened the door and saw my neighbor, a cute 18 year old girl who I had met in the morning going so school. She asked me to fuck her asshole straight off the bat! For a moment, I was stunned. She was a decent girl, and I knew she had a boyfriend. But then she explained how she wanted to do it with her boyfriend and that she needed some prep. All the girls in her school had tried anal sex. I said okay. She got undressed, pulling down her jeans and exposing her cute ass. Oh, man, I always knew she was hot, but now that I saw her pristine white skin, her tight young body, and gorgeous pussy, my jaw dropped! I licked her pussy and caressed her anus with my finger at the same time. I even let her play with my wife’s anal plug. She was happy to finally have her tight asshole relaxed and stretchy. I pulled the toy out of her ass and it was her turn to prepare my dick for her tight asshole. Her sweet mouth made my dick so hard and throbbing! Then the big moment arrived. Cute naked girl got into the position, and I slowly slid my big dick into that super tight virgin asshole. It had to be the tightest, hottest hole I had ever stuck my dick into. She screamed and I immediately took it out. She gave me a sign, so I put it back in. I told her not to worry. I rimmed her asshole, and when it was soft enough, I slid my dick back inside. Now she wasn’t screaming. She was moaning in pleasure. The sight of her perfect, firm ass being fucked by my big dick was incredible! I fucked her virgin asshole gently for about an hour and then unloaded in her asshole so that she could remember me for the rest of her life!